Homes for Rent in Bay Harbor Islands, FL
103 rentals in Bay Harbor Islands
Market overview
Total active
103
Avg rent
$6,130.87
Median rent
$3,950.00
Rent range
$1,600.00 – $39,000.00
Rent/sqft
$4.33
Premium ($5K+/mo)
41
There are 103 active rental listings in Bay Harbor Islands, FL. Median monthly rent in Bay Harbor Islands is $3,950. Eight in ten listings ask between $2,120 and $11,500 monthly. On a per-square-foot basis, rents run about $4.33. Bay Harbor Islands also has 166 properties on the for-sale market. Bay Harbor Islands sits in Miami-dade County.
Bay Harbor Islands market data
| Homes for sale | 166 |
|---|---|
| Median price | $1,539,500 |
| Typical range (8 in 10) | $350,000 – $4,805,000 |
| Price per square foot | $1,425 |
| Homes for rent | 103 |
| Median rent | $3,950/mo |
| Rent range (8 in 10) | $2,120 – $11,500 |
| Rent per square foot | $4.33 |
| Waterfront | 86 |
| With private pool | 22 |
| In 55+ communities | 43 |
MLS data as of September 22, 2026.
The Bay Harbor Islands rental market currently offers 103 homes. By property type: 28 single-family, 67 condo, 8 townhome. Median rent: $3,950 per month. Typical range: $2,120 to $11,500 per month. Average rent per square foot: $4.33. For comparison, the for-sale market holds 166 listings at a median of $1,539,500. All numbers come from the MLS feed as of 2026-09-22.
In Bay Harbor Islands, the gap between a good rental and a great one is usually in the details: which utilities are included, how long approval takes, and what the association allows.
Steady supply of annual leases, with demand peaking between November and April.
Frequently asked questions
- What do I need to rent in Bay Harbor Islands?
- Typically an application with credit and background check, proof of income (2.5 to 3 times the rent is common) and valid ID. At signing, first month, last month and a security deposit are standard.
- What is the minimum lease term in Bay Harbor Islands?
- Many communities require 12 months and cap how many times per year a unit can be rented. Some allow 3 to 6 month seasonal terms, usually at a higher monthly rate.
- How long does association approval take in Bay Harbor Islands?
- In HOA or condo communities the process usually runs 15 to 30 days and includes an application fee per adult. Start it as soon as your offer is accepted — it is the step that most often delays move-in.
📡
Market Pulse
Based on 80 closed leases in Bay Harbor Islands · last 12 months
💰
Median Closed Rent
$4,175
from closed leases
📅
Avg. Days on Market
38 days
from list to signed lease
📊
Absorption Rate
14.5%
of inventory leased per month
Source: Spark MLS · Updated every 6h
Search by feature in Bay Harbor Islands
Popular searches in Bay Harbor Islands
Condos in Bay Harbor Islands154 listingsPet Friendly in Bay Harbor Islands142 listingsWith Garage in Bay Harbor Islands131 listingsLuxury Homes in Bay Harbor Islands99 listingsImpact Glass Homes in Bay Harbor Islands87 listingsWaterfront in Bay Harbor Islands86 listings2 Bedrooms in Bay Harbor Islands67 listingsNew Construction Homes in Bay Harbor Islands52 listings55+ Homes in Bay Harbor Islands43 listingsIntracoastal Homes in Bay Harbor Islands41 listingsHomes Under $500K in Bay Harbor Islands39 listings3 Bedrooms in Bay Harbor Islands39 listings1 Bedroom in Bay Harbor Islands31 listingsHomes $500K–$1M in Bay Harbor Islands28 listingsOcean View Homes in Bay Harbor Islands26 listingsPool Homes in Bay Harbor Islands22 listingsFurnished Homes in Bay Harbor Islands21 listings4 Bedrooms in Bay Harbor Islands19 listingsNo HOA in Bay Harbor Islands10 listings5+ Bedrooms in Bay Harbor Islands9 listingsSingle Family in Bay Harbor Islands8 listingsTownhomes in Bay Harbor Islands4 listings
Top communities in Bay Harbor Islands
- Bay Harbor Island72 listings
- Bay Harbour Island22 listings
- Bay Harbor Islands12 listings
- The Well Bay Harbor11 listings
- Island Pointe Condo8 listings
- Blair House Condo - West7 listings
- Bay harbor One condo6 listings
- Chatillon Hall Condominiu6 listings
- Kai AT Bay Harbor Condo6 listings
- Onda Residences6 listings
- 9900 West5 listings
- Bay Harbor Towers5 listings
Other cities near Bay Harbor Islands
Contact options
Stay updated with new rentals in Bay Harbor Islands. Get notified when properties matching your criteria hit the market.
Email alerts
Listings in Bay Harbor Islands
Active · Bay Harbor Islands
$4,500
1025 92 706, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154 · Bay Harbor Islands · FL 33154
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,278 sqft
View detailsActive · Bay Harbor Islands
$8,500
9901 W Bay Harbor Drive 401, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154 · Bay Harbor Islands · FL 33154
3 bd · 4 ba · 1,670 sqft
Pool
View detailsActive · Bay Harbor Islands
$9,500
10090 Bay Harbor Terrace 10090, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154 · Bay Harbor Islands · FL 33154
3 bd · 4 ba · 1,680 sqft
View detailsActive · Bay Harbor Islands
$3,000
9381 E Bay Harbor Drive 202S, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154 · Bay Harbor Islands · FL 33154
1 bd · 1 ba · 1,125 sqft
Pool
View detailsActive · Bay Harbor Islands
$2,595
9770 E Bay Harbor Drive 6S, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154 · Bay Harbor Islands · FL 33154
2 bd · 1 ba · 900 sqft
Pool
View detailsActive · Bay Harbor Islands
$3,250
9500 W Bay Harbor Drive 7D, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154 · Bay Harbor Islands · FL 33154
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,100 sqft
WaterfrontPool
View details
↓ Price dropActive · Bay Harbor Islands
$6,500
1133 102nd Street 403, Bay Harbor Islands, FL 33154 · Bay Harbor Islands · FL 33154
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,260 sqft
Furnished
View details