Homes for Sale in Bay Harbor Islands, FL

Bay Harbor Islands, FL, has 166 homes for sale. Median price is $1,539,500. Typical range: $350,000 to $4,805,000. Inventory includes 8 single-family, 154 condo, 4 townhome. Average price per square foot is $1,425. There are 99 luxury listings ($1M+). 41 transactions closed in Bay Harbor Islands over the past year. The median closed price was $690,000. Average time from listing to contract was 144 days. Closed prices averaged 93.9% of the asking price. Roughly 5.9% of inventory sells each month. Looking at what the Bay Harbor Islands listings actually offer: 86 of the homes for sale in Bay Harbor Islands sit on waterfront lots. 22 listings include a private pool. 131 come with garage parking. 43 are located in 55+ communities. 156 carry a homeowners association. On the rental side, Bay Harbor Islands has 103 homes for rent, with a median asking rent of $3,950 per month. Eight in ten of those fall between $2,120 and $11,500. That is about $4.33 per square foot. Much of the inventory sits in Bay Harbor Island and Bay Harbour Island. Figures reflect MLS data as of 2026-09-22. Bay Harbor Islands is in Miami-dade County.