Homes for Rent in Cutler Bay, FL
156 rentals in Cutler Bay
Market overview
Total active
156
Avg rent
$2,671.66
Median rent
$2,400.00
Rent range
$1,000.00 – $8,500.00
Rent/sqft
$0.17
Premium ($5K+/mo)
7
Cutler Bay currently lists 156 rentals on the market. Half of the rentals here ask more than $2,400 a month, and half ask less. The typical range runs $1,425–$4,200 per month. On a per-square-foot basis, rents run about $0.17. Cutler Bay also has 250 properties on the for-sale market. Cutler Bay sits in Miami-dade County.
Cutler Bay market data
| Homes for sale | 250 |
|---|---|
| Median price | $629,000 |
| Typical range (8 in 10) | $329,950 – $990,100 |
| Price per square foot | $365 |
| Homes for rent | 156 |
| Median rent | $2,400/mo |
| Rent range (8 in 10) | $1,425 – $4,200 |
| Rent per square foot | $0.17 |
| Waterfront | 22 |
| With private pool | 73 |
| In gated communities | 3 |
| In 55+ communities | 61 |
MLS data as of October 19, 2026.
156 rental homes are on the market across Cutler Bay. By property type: 76 single-family, 43 condo, 37 townhome. Median rent: $2,400 per month. Typical range: $1,425 to $4,200 per month. Average rent per square foot: $0.17. For comparison, the for-sale market holds 250 listings at a median of $629,000. All numbers come from the MLS feed as of 2026-10-19.
Renting in Cutler Bay rewards moving fast: well-located units get committed within days, and many communities require association approval before you can sign.
Healthy turnover in the mid-range, with furnished units available for shorter stays.
Frequently asked questions
- What is the minimum lease term in Cutler Bay?
- Many communities require 12 months and cap how many times per year a unit can be rented. Some allow 3 to 6 month seasonal terms, usually at a higher monthly rate.
- Do Cutler Bay rentals allow pets?
- That is set by each association, not by the city. Weight caps, breed limits and a maximum number of animals are common, along with a pet fee or additional deposit. Get the rules in writing before you apply.
- Do I need renters insurance in Cutler Bay?
- Many landlords and associations require it in the lease. It covers your belongings plus liability, and the annual cost is usually low relative to what it protects.
📡
Market Pulse
Based on 174 closed leases in Cutler Bay · last 12 months
💰
Median Closed Rent
$2,500
from closed leases
📅
Avg. Days on Market
26 days
from list to signed lease
📊
Absorption Rate
23.3%
of inventory leased per month
Source: Spark MLS · Updated every 6h
Search by feature in Cutler Bay
Popular searches in Cutler Bay
Single Family in Cutler Bay180 listingsPet Friendly in Cutler Bay158 listingsWith Garage in Cutler Bay149 listingsHomes $500K–$1M in Cutler Bay145 listings3 Bedrooms in Cutler Bay120 listingsNo HOA in Cutler Bay96 listingsHomes Under $500K in Cutler Bay81 listingsImpact Glass Homes in Cutler Bay76 listingsPool Homes in Cutler Bay73 listings4 Bedrooms in Cutler Bay66 listings55+ Homes in Cutler Bay61 listingsTownhomes in Cutler Bay40 listings5+ Bedrooms in Cutler Bay36 listingsCondos in Cutler Bay30 listings2 Bedrooms in Cutler Bay27 listingsLuxury Homes in Cutler Bay24 listingsWaterfront in Cutler Bay22 listingsNew Construction Homes in Cutler Bay7 listingsFurnished Homes in Cutler Bay4 listingsGated Communities in Cutler Bay3 listings1 Bedroom in Cutler Bay1 listings
Top communities in Cutler Bay
- Cutler Cay28 listings
- The Courts AT Bayshore II24 listings
- The Courts AT Bayshore I16 listings
- Whispering Pines Estates14 listings
- A A Dooley Sub11 listings
- Saga Bay Gardens Condo11 listings
- Saga Bay Townhomes11 listings
- The Shores Condo NO 19 listings
- Lakes BY The Bay Gee8 listings
- LE Club AT Old Cutler Con8 listings
- Lakes BY The Bay Eve Repl7 listings
- Lakes BY The Bay Jay7 listings
Other cities near Cutler Bay
Contact options
Stay updated with new rentals in Cutler Bay. Get notified when properties matching your criteria hit the market.
Email alerts
Listings in Cutler Bay
Active · Cutler Bay
$1,950
19600 SW 110th Court 214, Cutler Bay, FL 33157 · Cutler Bay · FL 33157
2 bd · 1 ba · 889 sqft
View detailsActive · Cutler Bay
$1,950
19760 SW 103rd Court 102, Cutler Bay, FL 33157 · Cutler Bay · FL 33157
2 bd · 2 ba · 833 sqft
View detailsActive · Cutler Bay
$7,250
7713 SW 193rd Street, Cutler Bay, FL 33157 · Cutler Bay · FL 33157
5 bd · 5 ba · 4,149 sqft
View detailsActive · Cutler Bay
$3,750
9044 SW 212th Lane, Cutler Bay, FL 33189 · Cutler Bay · FL 33189
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,530 sqft
View details
NewActive · Cutler Bay
$3,600
8936 SW 228th Lane, Cutler Bay, FL 33190 · Cutler Bay · FL 33190
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,445 sqft
View detailsActive · Cutler Bay
$2,200
22631 SW 88th Place 15-18, Cutler Bay, FL 33190 · Cutler Bay · FL 33190
3 bd · 3 ba · 1,515 sqft
View detailsActive · Cutler Bay
$3,250
9730 Marlin Road 9730, Cutler Bay, FL 33157 · Cutler Bay · FL 33157
3 bd · 1 ba · 1,462 sqft
Pool
View details