Homes for Sale in Cutler Bay, FL

Cutler Bay, FL, has 250 homes for sale. Median price is $629,000. Typical range: $329,950 to $990,100. Inventory includes 180 single-family, 30 condo, 40 townhome. Average price per square foot is $365. There are 24 luxury listings ($1M+). 163 transactions closed in Cutler Bay over the past year. The median closed price was $585,000. Average time from listing to contract was 73 days. Closed prices averaged 97.7% of the asking price. Roughly 13.9% of inventory sells each month. Feature by feature, the Cutler Bay market breaks down like this. 22 of the homes for sale in Cutler Bay sit on waterfront lots. 73 listings include a private pool. 149 come with garage parking. 3 sit inside gated communities. 61 are located in 55+ communities. 154 carry a homeowners association. On the rental side, Cutler Bay has 156 homes for rent, with a median asking rent of $2,400 per month. Eight in ten of those fall between $1,425 and $4,200. That is about $0.17 per square foot. Cutler Cay, The Courts AT Bayshore I, Whispering Pines Estates, Saga Bay Townhomes and Whispering Pines Est Sec are among the most active communities here. Figures reflect MLS data as of 2026-10-19. Cutler Bay is in Miami-dade County.